News Daily

The Times

Australia

  • Written by The Conversation

The race of Heathcliff, the brooding antihero of Emily Brontë’s 1847 novel Wuthering Heights, is a much-discussed element of the classic tale.

Brontë variously describes him as “a little lascar, or an American or Spanish castaway”; “that gipsy brat,” not “a regular black,” the offspring of the “Emperor of China,” and the son to an “Indian queen”.

But in her recent film adaptation, director Emerald Fennell has cast white Australian actor Jacob Elordi in the role. What does this mean for our understanding of the story?

Brontë’s Heathcliff wasn’t white. Jacob Elordi is. Is that a problem?
Few casting choices this year have divided audiences like Jacob Elordi as Fennel’s Heathcliff. Pierre Mouton/Warner Bros. Pictures

Is Heathcliff white?

Scholars, especially since the late 20th century, have debated Heathcliff’s racial identity without forming a consensus. They continue to examine the text for evidence.

He has been variously identified as Irish, a migrant fleeing famine; African, found at the Liverpool docks (then England’s largest slave trading port); or Romani, often shorthand for a racially ambiguous and “threatening” outsider.

I do not feel the novel invites us to identify Heathcliff with a fixed racial identity. The book’s strange, otherworldly and almost hallucinogenic nature resists clear interpretation.

In 19th century Britain, post-Enlightenment Europe and the United States, the concept of race was categorised and studied, and exerted a strong influence on government policies and popular culture.

People were placed into hierarchies of humanity to justify slavery, colonialism and genocide. This system of “scientific racism”, as it has come to be known, placed “whiteness” at the top.

But this notion of whiteness was different to the one we hold today, which explains Heathcliff’s racial “otherness” as being associated with Irishness.

Brontë’s novel, and Gothic fiction of the age more broadly, depicts race as something more malleable and fantastical.

In the case of Brontë’s Heathcliff, his racial identity seems to shift and morph, sometimes rendered supernatural and demonic in the eyes of other characters. His darkness and inhumanity is emphasised and seems to intensify in moments of brooding anger and villainy.

His complexion darkens and his eyes become, in the words of the maid Nelly, “black fiends” that glint and lurk “like the devil’s spies” with “a half-civilised ferocity”.

Heathcliff’s inhumanity, as tied to his non-whiteness, seemingly rises to the surface, as if the stain of his moral degradation seeps through his soul to appear on his face.

Critics of the casting

The casting of Elordi as Heathcliff has come under scrutiny.

Some readers and critics have interpreted Brontë’s book as a critique of British institutional racism in the late 18th century, when the novel is set, and the Victorian era (1837–1901), when it was written.

One such reading is that the novel links the oppression of white women to that of non-white subjects of the British Empire to critique social structures of violence, cruelty and inequality.

This reading sees the novel’s representation of female subjugation as a mirror image to the oppression that people of colour faced at the time.

Many critics of the film have said it isn’t an accurate adaptation, and misunderstands what Brontë’s text is really about. But an argument around “intent” is hard to make, since we can never really know what a novel “is about”. We can only guess.

And there are limitless interpretations of a text, especially one as strange and enigmatic as this one. As such, though race is a part of the original Wuthering Heights, assigning a singular, definitive meaning to the novel’s representation of race is complicated.

In Brontë’s novel, nothing is as it seems. The ever-shifting image of Heathcliff – at once appearing to be a lascar, a Native American, Spanish and Black – would be difficult to depict effectively on film.

Film lacks the imaginative malleability as the reader’s mind’s eye, which can hold all these descriptions of Heathcliff’s image at once, allowing this Gothic strangeness to occur.

Race in Fennell’s film

While Heathcliff is cast as white, Fennell casts people of colour in other roles.

Fennell’s film is not interested in the racial commentary many critics have found in Brontë’s novel. The characters in Fennel’s created world do not appear to engage with race the same way people do in our world.

American-Vietnamese actor Hong Chau plays Nelly Dean (a housemaid in the novel, but an illegitimate daughter to a nobleman in the film), and English/Scottish–Pakistani actor Shazad Latif portrays Edgar Linton, Cathy’s wealthy and respected husband.

The casting of Edgar, a man of wealth and status, as a person of colour undermines the intersections of oppression and race that existed at the time.

I think Fennell’s decision to ignore race is a missed opportunity to foster a more nuanced discussion of race in the late 18th century and Victorian Britain.

Brontë’s Heathcliff wasn’t white. Jacob Elordi is. Is that a problem?
Hong Chau (left) plays housemaid Nelly Dean and Shazad Latif (right) plays Cathy’s husband, Edgar Linton. Warner Bros. Pictures

Victorian Britain was shaped by its participation in the transatlantic slave trade, the presence of Black peoples on its soil (in some instances, enslaved), and its colonies in Asia and the Middle East.

While it would not have been common to find people of colour in the Yorkshire moors in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, Britain (including Yorkshire) wasn’t as white as is widely believed. Fennell had an opportunity to highlight this fact.

Instead, in the film’s casting of Elordi as Heathcliff and Latif as Linton, we see a reticence to engage with the question of racial oppression at all. While this doesn’t make the adaptation “wrong”, it adds to the film’s almost complete lack of depth.

Read more https://theconversation.com/brontes-heathcliff-wasnt-white-jacob-elordi-is-is-that-a-problem-276183

Split Corrugated Conduit for Flexible Cable Protection

For wiring assemblies in vehicles, machinery and equipment, choosing suitable cable protection helps keep cables organised and reduces direct contact with surrounding parts. Mojak Plastics supplies plastic tubing and conduit options for different installation needs, and split corrugated conduit can... Read more

Trailers Melbourne Buyers Can Compare: When Box Trailers Make Sense

For many homeowners, businesses and tradespeople, trailers Melbourne customers use every week need to be versatile enough for changing loads. A box trailer can be particularly useful because its enclosed sides help contain cargo while providing a straightforward loading area... Read more

Bottle Label Printing That Balances Design and Readability

Product labels need to attract attention while making information easy to find and understand. On a bottle, the available space may be limited by the container’s shape, so every design decision matters. Bottle label printing should account for visual hierarchy... Read more

Office Cleaning Melbourne: Planning a Consistent Workplace Routine

Businesses looking for office cleaning Melbourne need a plan that reflects the way their workplace operates. A clean office supports day-to-day organisation, helps shared spaces remain presentable and gives employees and visitors a more orderly environment. Eco Green Cleaning Management... Read more

Pinboard Solutions for Offices, Schools and Shared Information Spaces

Why a Pinboard Remains Useful A pinboard provides a simple way to display information that needs to remain visible without being rewritten. Lawdex supplies fabric and cork options for offices, schools, staff areas and other environments. A pinboard can be used... Read more

Retractable Hose Reel: A Practical Guide To Choosing The Right Hose Storage

A retractable hose reel can make hose storage more organised, accessible and practical in workshops, commercial facilities, service areas and other working environments. Instead of leaving a hose coiled across the floor or requiring staff to manually wind it after... Read more