News Daily

The Times

Australia

  • Written by The Conversation

When OpenAI launched ChatGPT-5 in August of last year, many academics scoffed at the tech company’s claims its new artificial intelligence (AI) model possessed “PhD-level” intelligence.

After all, how could systems so prone to hallucination, flawed reasoning, and sycophancy compete with the world’s brightest young minds?

Yet academics are now routinely using tools such as ChatGPT to assist them in their research in much the same way they might once have relied on PhD students. Perhaps the most famous example is the world’s best-known mathematician, Terence Tao, who reports using generative AI as a mathematical collaborator.

I myself was recently turned from a skeptic into a believer when, over the course of a few months, I carried out a research project using a range of generative AI tools to perform tasks which I’d normally carry out in collaboration with my PhD students.

But this experience also highlighted a hidden danger of AI – one that shows why it would be unwise for anybody, whether they’re an academic or not, to substitute AI for actual apprentices.

The engine-room of research production

PhD students are the engine-room of research production that underpins much scientific progress. Under guidance from their supervisors, they devise hypotheses and experiments, theorise mathematical models, write proofs, and draft research papers.

But doing a PhD is much more than cheap research labour. A PhD degree is an apprenticeship in research. Today’s students are tomorrow’s research leaders. To get there, students learn how to ask the right questions, how to critique findings and, ultimately, how to take responsibility for the science they produce.

Much of my own research develops mathematical models to explain why computer systems and programs are and – just as often – are not secure. This involves developing mathematical definitions and theories, stating theorems and writing logical proofs, but also implementing defensive programs that embody and validate the ideas of all of that mathematics.

Normally, each of these steps would be done in collaboration with a PhD student, with the student carrying out the bulk of the proof-writing and programming work under my supervision.

Using AI as a tool

In my recent project, however, I developed the key mathematical ideas in conversation with ChatGPT.

I used ChatGPT to state and refine the key mathematical definitions and theorems at the level of “pen-and-paper” mathematics, which I carefully checked for errors. I used Anthropic’s Claude Code tool to translate all the pen-and-paper mathematics into a computerised format, in which a very old-fashioned proof checking program could check the consistency of each logical reasoning step.

I even used Claude Code and ChatGPT to implement Python programs to show that the mathematical ideas could be applied in practice. I checked these programs to make sure they did indeed conform to the mathematics, just as I would if they had been written by a new PhD student.

All up, I’d estimate that in the equivalent of six weeks of full-time work with the help of generative AI, I was able to produce the kind of research that might otherwise have taken at least a year of work by a PhD student working under my supervision.

This is remarkable progress. And perhaps a little frightening.

A hidden danger

Many people have warned that overuse of generative AI might reduce research quality. I agree that AI needs to be used with care and that, ultimately, authors need to remain responsible for the research they produce at all stages throughout the research process.

However, there is another danger.

In my research project, the extra benefits in terms of productivity came at a significant cost to learning. Not my own; I think I learned just as much working with generative AI as I would had I been working with a PhD student on this project.

I’m talking about the student learning that was sacrificed.

At no stage during this project did I teach a student how to discern a worthwhile research problem from a mere intellectual curiosity, nor what it means to rigorously test a hypothesis, place a piece of research within its proper scientific context, or even how to convey one’s thoughts cogently or manage their time efficiently.

Good researchers are ones who are aware of the gaps in their knowledge, who view their own hypotheses with appropriate suspicion, and take intellectual responsibility for the work they carry out.

AI is poorly placed to do any of these things well.

University academics must approach the adoption of generative AI with caution, lest it upend the apprentice training model that has served it so well for generations.

Read more https://theconversation.com/a-phd-is-an-apprenticeship-in-research-we-cant-let-ai-take-that-away-277486

Split Corrugated Conduit for Flexible Cable Protection

For wiring assemblies in vehicles, machinery and equipment, choosing suitable cable protection helps keep cables organised and reduces direct contact with surrounding parts. Mojak Plastics supplies plastic tubing and conduit options for different installation needs, and split corrugated conduit can... Read more

Trailers Melbourne Buyers Can Compare: When Box Trailers Make Sense

For many homeowners, businesses and tradespeople, trailers Melbourne customers use every week need to be versatile enough for changing loads. A box trailer can be particularly useful because its enclosed sides help contain cargo while providing a straightforward loading area... Read more

Bottle Label Printing That Balances Design and Readability

Product labels need to attract attention while making information easy to find and understand. On a bottle, the available space may be limited by the container’s shape, so every design decision matters. Bottle label printing should account for visual hierarchy... Read more

Office Cleaning Melbourne: Planning a Consistent Workplace Routine

Businesses looking for office cleaning Melbourne need a plan that reflects the way their workplace operates. A clean office supports day-to-day organisation, helps shared spaces remain presentable and gives employees and visitors a more orderly environment. Eco Green Cleaning Management... Read more

Pinboard Solutions for Offices, Schools and Shared Information Spaces

Why a Pinboard Remains Useful A pinboard provides a simple way to display information that needs to remain visible without being rewritten. Lawdex supplies fabric and cork options for offices, schools, staff areas and other environments. A pinboard can be used... Read more

Retractable Hose Reel: A Practical Guide To Choosing The Right Hose Storage

A retractable hose reel can make hose storage more organised, accessible and practical in workshops, commercial facilities, service areas and other working environments. Instead of leaving a hose coiled across the floor or requiring staff to manually wind it after... Read more