News Daily

The Times

Australia

  • Written by The Conversation

Canada has signed more than 70 treaties with its Indigenous peoples. The United States has more than 300 treaties. Our neighbour, New Zealand, has the Treaty of Waitangi. Countries such as Ecuador, Norway and Finland recognise Indigenous sovereignty through other devices, such as constitutional recognition and a Sámi Parliament.

In fact, Australia is the only major Commonwealth country not to have formally recognised that its Indigenous people have an inherent right to sovereignty: that is, the power to govern aspects of their own affairs. The Mabo decision dealt with Aboriginal land rights, but the question of Aboriginal sovereignty was left to languish.

That might now be open to change. My new research just published in the University of New South Wales Law Journal has found a long-forgotten legal rule that can clear the way for the High Court to hear cases about First Nations sovereignty.

This could result in cases as significant as Mabo, potentially transforming Indigenous rights in Australia.

The deadlock rule

For around 50 years, the High Court has consistently said all questions about First Nations sovereignty fall outside its jurisdiction – that the court does not have the power to hear such cases.

This started in 1979, with a case called Coe v Commonwealth.

Normally the High Court sits with an odd number of judges. This prevents deadlocks. But in Coe, there were only four High Court judges, who split two and two on the early procedural question of whether the court should allow a trial on sovereignty.

That meant their vote was a stalemate, so the case did not go to trial.

Since then, legal thinking has accepted the outcome of that 1970s case and assumed the High Court doesn’t have the power to hear cases on sovereignty.

This has turned out to be an error. Because it was a stalemate, or a deadlock vote, and not a decision on which the court had a majority verdict one way or the other, the case does not count as a valid precedent. A legal precedent is a decision that must be followed in all subsequent cases.

This is because there is a long-forgotten legal rule that explicitly says deadlocked decisions like this do not create a precedent. Cases in the 1930s and 1960s support this rule.

As a deadlocked decision, Coe v Commonwealth did not create any valid legal precedent. Legally, it is as if the case never happened, leaving behind a clean slate to start again.

Which, in turn, means it is open to the High Court to agree to hear any case on Indigenous sovereignty that is put forward.

So, where to from here?

There are three possible outcomes.

None of them include Australia’s Indigenous peoples “taking your backyard”, as the scare campaign over Mabo insisted.

All other major Commonwealth countries have managed to acknowledge Indigenous sovereignty without their systems of government being undermined. This is because multiple sovereignties can exist at the same time and work together, such as Australia’s state and federal governments.

It will now be up to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples to decide whether to run a new test case. If they choose to do that, the High Court might continue to claim it has no jurisdiction and leave it to the political arena.

If the High Court did agree to hear a case, there would be a trial. The court would have the power to decide whether – at least in terms of Australian law – First Nations sovereignty does, or does not, exist.

If the court rejected sovereignty, this could be devastating for Indigenous people, rather like the outcome of the Voice referendum.

But if sovereignty were recognised, this would be hugely significant, like another Mabo. It could potentially open legal avenues to more treaties, self-determination and reparations for First Nations people in Australia.

While Victoria already signed its own statewide treaty last year, no others exist in Australia.

What difference would it make?

The evidence suggests recognition of sovereignty, and implementing it in social systems, can make a huge difference to the wellbeing of Indigenous peoples.

One of Canada’s many successful examples of Indigenous sovereignty is a treaty between a First Nation called the Nisga’a and both the federal and provincial governments.

Before the treaty was signed in 2000, the Nisga’a had poorer health compared to non-Indigenous communities, greater interaction with criminal justice systems, lower life expectancy, and a whole range of problems that come from intergenerational trauma as a result of colonisation.

Since the treaty was signed, giving the Nisga’a decision-making control through their own level of government, the statistics in that community have greatly improved. Life has got better.

And that would be the biggest potential change of all.

Read more https://theconversation.com/i-rediscovered-a-forgotten-legal-rule-it-could-transform-indigenous-rights-in-australia-280730

Split Corrugated Conduit for Flexible Cable Protection

For wiring assemblies in vehicles, machinery and equipment, choosing suitable cable protection helps keep cables organised and reduces direct contact with surrounding parts. Mojak Plastics supplies plastic tubing and conduit options for different installation needs, and split corrugated conduit can... Read more

Trailers Melbourne Buyers Can Compare: When Box Trailers Make Sense

For many homeowners, businesses and tradespeople, trailers Melbourne customers use every week need to be versatile enough for changing loads. A box trailer can be particularly useful because its enclosed sides help contain cargo while providing a straightforward loading area... Read more

Bottle Label Printing That Balances Design and Readability

Product labels need to attract attention while making information easy to find and understand. On a bottle, the available space may be limited by the container’s shape, so every design decision matters. Bottle label printing should account for visual hierarchy... Read more

Office Cleaning Melbourne: Planning a Consistent Workplace Routine

Businesses looking for office cleaning Melbourne need a plan that reflects the way their workplace operates. A clean office supports day-to-day organisation, helps shared spaces remain presentable and gives employees and visitors a more orderly environment. Eco Green Cleaning Management... Read more

Pinboard Solutions for Offices, Schools and Shared Information Spaces

Why a Pinboard Remains Useful A pinboard provides a simple way to display information that needs to remain visible without being rewritten. Lawdex supplies fabric and cork options for offices, schools, staff areas and other environments. A pinboard can be used... Read more

Retractable Hose Reel: A Practical Guide To Choosing The Right Hose Storage

A retractable hose reel can make hose storage more organised, accessible and practical in workshops, commercial facilities, service areas and other working environments. Instead of leaving a hose coiled across the floor or requiring staff to manually wind it after... Read more