News Daily

The Times

Australia

  • Written by The Conversation

As debate rages about the federal government’s plan to lift the tax on earnings on superannuation balances over A$3 million, it’s worth revisiting why we offer super tax breaks in the first place, and why they need to be reformed.

Tax breaks on super contributions mean less tax is paid on super savings than other forms of income. These tax breaks cost the federal budget nearly $50 billion in lost revenue each year.

These tax breaks boost the retirement savings of super fund members. They also ensure workers don’t pay punitively high long-term tax rates on their super, since the impact of even low tax rates on savings compounds over time.

But they disproportionately flow to older and wealthier Australians.

Two thirds of the value of super tax breaks benefit the top 20% of income earners, who are already saving enough for their retirement.

Few retirees draw down on their retirement savings as intended, and many are net savers – their super balance continues to grow for decades after they retire.

By 2060, Treasury expects one-third of all withdrawals from super will be via bequests – up from one-fifth today.

Superannuation in Australia was intended to help fund retirements. Instead, it has become a taxpayer-subsidised inheritance scheme.

The tax breaks aren’t just inequitable; they are economically unsound. Generous tax breaks for super savers mean other taxes (such as income and company taxes) must be higher to make up the forgone revenue. That means the burden falls disproportionately on younger taxpayers.

The government should go further

The government’s plan to increase the tax rate on superannuation earnings for balances exceeding $3 million from 15% to 30% is one modest step towards fixing these problems. The tax would only apply to the amount over $3 million, not the entire balance.

This reform will affect only the top 0.5% of super account holders – about 80,000 people – and save more than $2 billion a year in its first full year.

Claims that not indexing the $3 million threshold will result in the tax affecting most younger Australians, or that it will somehow disproportionately affect younger generations, are simply nonsense.

Rather than being the biggest losers from the lack of indexation, younger Australians are the biggest beneficiaries. It means more older, wealthier Australians will shoulder some of the burden of budget repair and an ageing population. Otherwise, younger generations would bear this burden alone.

The facts speak for themselves: a mere 0.5% of Australians have more than $3 million in their super, and 85% of those are aged over 60.

Even in the unlikely scenario where the threshold remains fixed until 2055 – or for ten consecutive parliamentary terms – it would still only affect the top 10% of retiring Australians. Treasurer Jim Chalmers has rightly pointed out that it is unlikely the threshold will never be lifted.

Far from abandoning the proposed $3 million threshold, the government should go further and drop the threshold to $2 million, and only then index it to inflation, saving the budget a further $1 billion a year.

Treasurer Jim Chalmers during a press conference.
Treasurer Jim Chalmers says the higher tax rate will affect less than 1% of super account holders. Lukas Coch/AAP

There is no rationale for offering such generous earnings tax breaks on super balances between $2 million and $3 million.

At the very least, if the $3 million threshold is maintained, it should not be indexed until inflation naturally reduces its real value to $2 million, which is estimated to occur around 2040.

Sure, it’s complicated

Levying a higher tax rate on the earnings of large super balances is complicated by the fact existing super earnings taxes are levied at the fund level, not on individual member accounts.

And it’s true that levying a 15% surcharge on the implied earnings of the account over the year (the change in account balance, net of contributions and withdrawals) will impose a tax on unrealised capital gains, or paper profits.

Taxing capital gains as they build up removes incentives to “lock in” investments to hold onto untaxed capital gains, as the Henry Tax Review recognised. But it can create cash flow problems for some self-managed super fund members who hold assets such as business premises or a farm in their fund.

Yet there are seldom easy answers when it comes to tax changes.

Most people with such substantial super balances are retirees who already maintain enough liquid assets to meet the minimum drawdown requirements.

Indeed, self-managed super funds are legally obligated to have investment strategies that ensure liquidity and the ability to meet liabilities.

In any case, the tax does not have to be paid from super. Australians with large super balances typically earn as much income from investments outside super. And the wealthiest 10% of retirees today rely more on income from outside super than income from super.

Good policy is always the art of the compromise

Australia faces the twin challenges of big budget deficits and stagnant productivity. Tax reform will be needed to respond to both.

Good public policy, like politics, always requires some level of compromise.

Super tax breaks should exist only where they support a policy aim. And on balance, trimming unneeded super tax breaks for the wealthiest 0.5% of Australians would make our super system fairer and our budget stronger.

Read more https://theconversation.com/actually-gen-z-stand-to-be-the-biggest-winners-from-the-new-3-million-super-tax-257450

Split Corrugated Conduit for Flexible Cable Protection

For wiring assemblies in vehicles, machinery and equipment, choosing suitable cable protection helps keep cables organised and reduces direct contact with surrounding parts. Mojak Plastics supplies plastic tubing and conduit options for different installation needs, and split corrugated conduit can... Read more

Trailers Melbourne Buyers Can Compare: When Box Trailers Make Sense

For many homeowners, businesses and tradespeople, trailers Melbourne customers use every week need to be versatile enough for changing loads. A box trailer can be particularly useful because its enclosed sides help contain cargo while providing a straightforward loading area... Read more

Bottle Label Printing That Balances Design and Readability

Product labels need to attract attention while making information easy to find and understand. On a bottle, the available space may be limited by the container’s shape, so every design decision matters. Bottle label printing should account for visual hierarchy... Read more

Office Cleaning Melbourne: Planning a Consistent Workplace Routine

Businesses looking for office cleaning Melbourne need a plan that reflects the way their workplace operates. A clean office supports day-to-day organisation, helps shared spaces remain presentable and gives employees and visitors a more orderly environment. Eco Green Cleaning Management... Read more

Pinboard Solutions for Offices, Schools and Shared Information Spaces

Why a Pinboard Remains Useful A pinboard provides a simple way to display information that needs to remain visible without being rewritten. Lawdex supplies fabric and cork options for offices, schools, staff areas and other environments. A pinboard can be used... Read more

Retractable Hose Reel: A Practical Guide To Choosing The Right Hose Storage

A retractable hose reel can make hose storage more organised, accessible and practical in workshops, commercial facilities, service areas and other working environments. Instead of leaving a hose coiled across the floor or requiring staff to manually wind it after... Read more