News Daily

The Times

Australia

  • Written by The Conversation

Climate change has killed billions of corals and fundamentally changed coral reefs. The response, especially in Australia, has been to fix the symptoms, not address the cause – climate change for which humans are responsible.

Much money and research effort is expended in replacing, regrowing and supporting corals, in the hope reefs may survive a warmer world.

These technological and scientific “solutions” give hope that something can be done. But as we argue in Nature Climate Change today, there is little evidence these measures will create resilient or healthy reef ecosystems over the long term.

Humanity must take dramatic action on climate change. By focusing so much attention on treating the symptoms – such as replacing dead corals – we risk squandering money, time and public trust in science.

We believe coral restoration may be, at best, a feel-good measure that satisfies a human urge to do something about climate change – and at worst, a dangerous distraction from climate action. A fundamental rethink is needed.

diver floats above coral reef
Climate change has killed billions of corals. WWF via AAP

What to do about our troubled reefs?

The world’s coral reefs have suffered devastating damage due to climate change and resulting warmer seas. This includes the Great Barrier Reef, which last summer experienced yet another mass bleaching.

Clearly, something must be done.

In recent years, a popular solution has emerged in the form of direct scientific interventions. These include:

  • growing baby corals in a nursery to later plant them on an ocean reef

  • selective breeding, which involves identifying heat-tolerant corals, collecting their eggs and sperm, and breeding heat-tolerant offspring

  • minimising stressors, for example, cloud-seeding or building structures to shade coral, pumping cooler water onto reefs or removing natural predators such as crown-of-thorns starfish.

Such interventions attract substantial research and philanthropic funding. But many scientists, including us, are concerned about their growing popularity.

There is little compelling evidence these interventions improve outcomes across coral reef ecosystems.

For example, a 2020 study synthesised current knowledge in coral reef restoration. It found 60% of projects had monitored restored sites for less than 18 months. Most projects were small-scale, with a median restored area of 100 square metres.

It concluded coral restoration projects were poorly designed, lacked clear and achievable objectives, and improvements were needed in monitoring and reporting.

Another study last year found some forms of coral rehabilitation “may be feasible, affordable, and ethical”, but the benefits were small and the measures expensive.

The researchers said legislation and policy should concentrate on “bolstering ecosystem resilience by reducing greenhouse gas emissions and other drivers of reef degradation”.

man underwater with coral
A diver in the United States clips a fragment of coral to be transplanted from a coral nursery to a reef – one method of coral restoration. Wilfredo Lee/AP

We don’t always have to ‘do something’ on reefs

In some areas of science, such as human health, people have been shown to prefer solutions that involve active intervention: that is, adding something new, regardless of evidence for or against its efficacy. The same “intervention bias” may be influencing how we try to help coral reefs.

A vast literature on coral reefs calls for action in the form of scientific intervention.

However, resilience, recovery and change are an inherent feature of natural ecosystems. This was demonstrated by a review of 400 studies of disturbed ecosystems, which showed human restoration provided no consistent benefits over natural recovery.

Recent evidence from the northern Great Barrier Reef, following a major bleaching event, supports the idea that, in the short-term at least, nature can recover on its own. There, coral cover jumped from 10% in 2016, the lowest ever recorded, to an ephemeral but record high of 36% just six years later.

This is not to say the bounce-back will last. Heatwaves will continue to kill regrown corals, rendering this natural success temporary. That’s why drastic emissions reduction is essential.

steam from coal plant
Cutting carbon emissions is the most important action humanity can take to save coral reefs. Robert Bowmer/AP

What is a healthy reef?

Intervention on coral reefs usually aims to increase live coral cover. This approach rests on the assumption that more coral leads to healthy reefs.

Corals are undoubtedly a foundational and iconic part of coral reefs. But corals and reefs are not the same. Corals are important, iconic organisms. Coral reefs are highly diverse, complex ecological systems composed of thousands of animal, plant and bacteria species.

The science is not clear on whether more corals will return reefs to a “healthy” state, especially given such scientific interventions are usually small in scale. There is also evidence suggesting reefs can grow, even when coral species decline.

More science is needed to determine what a “healthy” reef is. A pretty reef with plenty of coral? A usable reef with plenty of fish? Or a reef that is unspoiled by human activity?

And there’s another important research question to answer: how can humanity come to terms with reefs transformed by climate change?

coral reef with fish
Reef health is not just about corals. Darren England/AAP

Towards transformative solutions

We do not seek to divide reef scientists into camps “for and against” coral restoration.

But we are not confident that specific, targeted coral interventions will have wider benefits. What’s needed is broader, evidence-based investigation into transformation across reefs and human communities - to bring about real, large-scale solutions.

We realise our position may be considered controversial. But the stakes are high – and an evidence-based approach to caring for coral reefs is urgently needed.

Read more https://theconversation.com/coral-restoration-is-a-speculative-feel-good-science-that-wont-save-our-reefs-235657

Split Corrugated Conduit for Flexible Cable Protection

For wiring assemblies in vehicles, machinery and equipment, choosing suitable cable protection helps keep cables organised and reduces direct contact with surrounding parts. Mojak Plastics supplies plastic tubing and conduit options for different installation needs, and split corrugated conduit can... Read more

Trailers Melbourne Buyers Can Compare: When Box Trailers Make Sense

For many homeowners, businesses and tradespeople, trailers Melbourne customers use every week need to be versatile enough for changing loads. A box trailer can be particularly useful because its enclosed sides help contain cargo while providing a straightforward loading area... Read more

Bottle Label Printing That Balances Design and Readability

Product labels need to attract attention while making information easy to find and understand. On a bottle, the available space may be limited by the container’s shape, so every design decision matters. Bottle label printing should account for visual hierarchy... Read more

Office Cleaning Melbourne: Planning a Consistent Workplace Routine

Businesses looking for office cleaning Melbourne need a plan that reflects the way their workplace operates. A clean office supports day-to-day organisation, helps shared spaces remain presentable and gives employees and visitors a more orderly environment. Eco Green Cleaning Management... Read more

Pinboard Solutions for Offices, Schools and Shared Information Spaces

Why a Pinboard Remains Useful A pinboard provides a simple way to display information that needs to remain visible without being rewritten. Lawdex supplies fabric and cork options for offices, schools, staff areas and other environments. A pinboard can be used... Read more

Retractable Hose Reel: A Practical Guide To Choosing The Right Hose Storage

A retractable hose reel can make hose storage more organised, accessible and practical in workshops, commercial facilities, service areas and other working environments. Instead of leaving a hose coiled across the floor or requiring staff to manually wind it after... Read more